• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Go to Positive Money Europe
  • Go to Positive Money US

Positive Money

Making money and banking work for society

  • About us
    • Our vision
    • Who we are
    • History & highlights
    • Contact us
    • Current vacancies
    • In the media
    • Funding & Annual Reports
  • What we do
    • Educate & empower
    • Research and Policy
    • Campaign & local groups
    • Influence decision makers
    • In the media
    • International Movement
    • Events
  • Resources
    • Videos
    • Publications
    • Local group resources
    • Lobby your MP
    • Organise an Event
    • Policy resources
    • Shop
  • Press
  • Blog
  • Donate
  • Positive Money Europe
  • Positive Money US

Our response to critics in the Cambridge Journal of Economics

by Ben Dyson (formerly Positive Money)

The Cambridge Journal of Economics (probably the leading journal of Post-Keynesian economics) has published an entire special issue on “Cranks and brave heretics: Rethinking money and banking after the Great Financial Crisis”, inviting a range of academics to comment on proposals to stop banks creating money (amongst other ideas for monetary reform).

It is great to see this debate growing in academic circles. The Cambridge Journal of Economics deserves much credit for trying to stimulate the discussion on monetary and banking reform.

Our response to a couple of the most critical papers has now been published in the journal. Normally you would need an academic journal subscription to access it, but readers of this blog can access it for free in PDF format.

From our introduction:

“We wish to address four main concerns raised by F&S [Guiseppe Fontana & Malcolm Sawyer] and N&W [Yeva Nersisyan & Randall L. Wray] in this issue. First, F&S focus on a sovereign money system’s impact on government finances, arguing that it would place constraints on fiscal policy that do not exist today. We argue that there is in fact no difference as far as the Treasury’s policy space is concerned. Second, both papers claim that prohibiting money creation by banks would be economically destructive: in N&W’s words, it would ‘run our economy into the ground’ (N&W, 2016, p. 25). We argue that the reality of bank lending and firm investment is a challenge to this assumption and ignores the fact that the central bank can always create money to finance lending to the real economy. Third, we address the argument that if money creation by banks is prohibited, then money creation in the form of ‘near monies’ will simply shift to the shadow banking sector. Finally, we address the claim that financial instability has its real source in the shadow banking sector, so that our focus on commercial banks is misplaced. Space does not allow us to address many of the other points made by F&S, but their omission from this response does not imply our acceptance of those arguments.”

Read the rest of the response in PDF format.

There’s also some interesting analysis of the debate by Geoff Tily over at the Prime Economics blog.

The fact that more and more academics are beginning to engage in these topics shows that the work Positive Money is doing is starting to have an impact on the wider academic and policy debate.

Economic Analysis, Theory, Options for Banking Reform, Understanding Money & Debt

Ben Dyson (formerly Positive Money)

Ben Dyson was Positive Money's Head of Research until December 2016. He is a co-author of Modernising Money: why our monetary system is broken, and how it can be fixed. Ben's research focuses on potential reforms to monetary policy, structural reforms to the banking system, and the potential for technology to disrupt the payment and banking systems.

Primary Sidebar

Get our latest campaign updates

Recent Posts

  • Concerns raised over vested interests of Lords pushing for financial deregulation
  • We need more than new homes: new census data confirms UK building stock is growing faster than population
  • 12 highlights from 2022
  • Positive Money at The World Transformed
  • Hunt financial deregulation announcement

Footer

Follow us on social media

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.


Privacy Policy, Terms & Conditions


Positive Money is a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales. Registered number 07253015.
Registered office: 104 Davina House, 137-149 Goswell Road, London EC1V 7ET.


Positive Money Europe